Top pizzeria in Aventura right now: Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Aventura

★ 4.8 · 6,932 reviews total#1 of 8 pizzeriasUpdated July 19, 2026View on map

Right now, the top-rated Pizzeria in Aventura is Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Aventura (4.9 stars).

Across Miami-Dade, Pizzeria read 0.97 stars lower on Yelp than Google.

See this week's best pizzerias list for Aventura.

Found 2 results

Sort

#	Business	Google rating	Yelp rating	Combined rating	vs avg	Google vs. Yelp	Price	Confidence
1	Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - AventuraAventura · Pizzeria Call Reserve	★ 4.96,752 reviews	★ 4.3180 reviews	★ 4.86,932 reviews totalGoogle 4.9 / Yelp 4.3	+0.4 vs pizzeria avg ★4.4+0.5 vs all ★4.3	▲ 0.6	$	high confidence Why this result? #1 of 8 · Pizzeria in Aventura · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 6,752 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet.
2	Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & WingsAventura · Pizzeria Call Reserve	★ 4.31,669 reviews	★ 3.8430 reviews	★ 4.12,099 reviews totalGoogle 4.3 / Yelp 3.8	-0.3 vs pizzeria avg ★4.4-0.2 vs all ★4.3	▲ 0.5	$	high confidence Why this result? #2 of 8 · Pizzeria in Aventura · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 1,669 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet.

8 businessesRankedRanked on Google reviews · Yelp shown for comparisonUpdated July 19, 2026View on map

Averages (Google-based): pizzeria cohort ★4.4 · all Miami-Dade venues ★4.3 (17,504 total).

Every ranking here uses public Google review data only. See the methodology.