Italian in Key Biscayne
11 businessesRanked by quality scoreRanked on Google reviews · Yelp shown for comparisonUpdated July 19, 2026View on map
Right now, the top-rated Italian in Key Biscayne is Tutto Pizza & Pasta (4.5 stars).
11 Italian food businesses in Key Biscayne, ranked by the same fused quality score (Google rating and review volume) used across the rest of the site, from public Google review data.
Filter
| # | Business | Google rating | Yelp rating | Combined rating | Google vs. Yelp | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tutto Pizza & Pasta | ▲ 0.8 | $$ | |||
| 2 | Sunset Point Wood Fired Pizzeria Key Biscayne Hidden gem | - | - | - | $ | |
| 3 | Sir Pizza | ▲ 0.6 | $ | |||
| 4 | Randazzo's Italian Restaurant Hidden gem | ▲ 0.2 | - | |||
| 5 | La Scala Italian Restaurant Hidden gem | ▼ 0.1 | $ | |||
| 6 | Amici at Key Biscayne Hidden gem | ▲ 0.6 | - | |||
| 7 | Italian Boutique Restaurant | - | - | - | - | |
| 8 | Luma | - | - | - | $$ | |
| 9 | Domino's Pizza | - | - | $ | ||
| 10 | Miami Slice Key Biscayne | - | - | - | $ | |
| 11 | Ristorante Forchetta | - | - | - |
See all categories in Key Biscayne · View Key Biscayne on the map
This ranking compares businesses across every type (restaurant, cafe, bakery, and more) using the same fused quality score used elsewhere on the site, not the type-specific leaderboards above. Every ranking here uses public Google review data only. See the methodology.