Platerian
Menu
ENES

Italian in Miami Beach

117 businessesRanked by quality scoreRanked on Google reviews · Yelp shown for comparisonUpdated July 19, 2026View on map

Right now, the top-rated Italian in Miami Beach is ll Pastaiolo (4.9 stars).

The biggest Google-vs-Yelp gap among Italian spots in Miami Beach is at Pizza Tua: Google rates it 4.8 stars, Yelp 3.3.

That's Amore has the most Google reviews among Italian spots in Miami Beach (13,496).

117 Italian food businesses in Miami Beach, ranked by the same fused quality score (Google rating and review volume) used across the rest of the site, from public Google review data.

Showing 100 of 117

Showing the top 100 of 117 ranked businesses.

#BusinessGoogle ratingYelp ratingCombined ratingGoogle vs. YelpPrice
1ll PastaioloMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.919,589 reviews★ 4.5673 reviews★ 4.820,262 reviews totalGoogle 4.9 / Yelp 4.5▲ 0.4$
2Il Pizzaiolo 🍋🩵 - Neapolitan Pizzeria Miami BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.95,340 reviews★ 4.565 reviews★ 4.95,405 reviews totalGoogle 4.9 / Yelp 4.5▲ 0.4$
3Piola Italian Restaurant Miami BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.911,924 reviews---$
4Osteria PositanoMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.910,956 reviews★ 4.6224 reviews★ 4.911,180 reviews totalGoogle 4.9 / Yelp 4.6▲ 0.3$
5Pane e VinoMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.98,423 reviews★ 4.82,778 reviews★ 4.911,201 reviews totalGoogle 4.9 / Yelp 4.8▲ 0.1$
6Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - South BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.93,670 reviews★ 4.61,052 reviews★ 4.84,722 reviews totalGoogle 4.9 / Yelp 4.6▲ 0.3$
7CORALLO 🇮🇹 Amalfi coastMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.94,827 reviews---$
8La Leggenda PizzeriaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.73,655 reviews★ 4.5678 reviews★ 4.64,333 reviews totalGoogle 4.7 / Yelp 4.5▲ 0.2$
9That's AmoreMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.813,496 reviews★ 4.3237 reviews★ 4.713,733 reviews totalGoogle 4.8 / Yelp 4.3▲ 0.5$$
10IL BologneseMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.813,119 reviews★ 3.4329 reviews★ 4.613,448 reviews totalGoogle 4.8 / Yelp 3.4▲ 1.4$
11Romina's Ristorante ItalianoMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.93,768 reviews★ 3.553 reviews★ 4.83,821 reviews totalGoogle 4.9 / Yelp 3.5▲ 1.4$
12Mercato della Pescheria Miami BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.89,150 reviews★ 4.51 reviews--$
13Pizza TuaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.87,943 reviews★ 3.371 reviews★ 4.78,014 reviews totalGoogle 4.8 / Yelp 3.3▲ 1.5$
14P.Pole Pizza Miami BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.91,228 reviews---$
15Cafe Prima PastaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.85,041 reviews★ 4.51,413 reviews★ 4.76,454 reviews totalGoogle 4.8 / Yelp 4.5▲ 0.3$
16Mega PizzaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.72,091 reviews★ 3.4163 reviews★ 4.42,254 reviews totalGoogle 4.7 / Yelp 3.4▲ 1.3$
17IT Italian Trattoria COLLINSMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.713,082 reviews★ 3.9361 reviews★ 4.613,443 reviews totalGoogle 4.7 / Yelp 3.9▲ 0.8$$
18Hosteria RomanaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.711,445 reviews★ 3.81,080 reviews★ 4.512,525 reviews totalGoogle 4.7 / Yelp 3.8▲ 0.9$
19Mercato Ocean DriveMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.91,825 reviews----
20Pummarola Miami Beach "Pizzeria Napoletana"Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.81,131 reviews★ 4.7127 reviews★ 4.81,258 reviews totalGoogle 4.8 / Yelp 4.7▲ 0.1$
21BOTTA Italian Street FoodMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.91,197 reviews★ 4.8137 reviews★ 4.91,334 reviews totalGoogle 4.9 / Yelp 4.8▲ 0.1$$
22Nick's Pizza South BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.71,523 reviews★ 3.9115 reviews★ 4.51,638 reviews totalGoogle 4.7 / Yelp 3.9▲ 0.8$
23Osteria da Fortunata - MiamiMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.73,333 reviews★ 3.4143 reviews★ 4.53,476 reviews totalGoogle 4.7 / Yelp 3.4▲ 1.3$
24DI MAURO´S ITALIAN RESTAURANT & PIZZERIAMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.73,310 reviews★ 4.4592 reviews★ 4.63,902 reviews totalGoogle 4.7 / Yelp 4.4▲ 0.3$
25Donatella RestaurantMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.91,122 reviews---$$
26KanoliMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.72,911 reviews★ 3.977 reviews★ 4.62,988 reviews totalGoogle 4.7 / Yelp 3.9▲ 0.8$
27Casa Amore - Best Italian restaurant South BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.81,492 reviews---$
28Banchero MiamiMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.62,306 reviews★ 4.1111 reviews★ 4.52,417 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.1▲ 0.5$
29Grafa PizzaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.62,304 reviews★ 4.0302 reviews★ 4.42,606 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.0▲ 0.6$
30Pizza De Miami 2Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.71,223 reviews★ 3.86 reviews--$
31Spris Artisan Pizza - Lincoln RoadMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.61,937 reviews★ 4.1675 reviews★ 4.42,612 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.1▲ 0.5$
32George's Restaurant & LoungeMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.62,046 reviews★ 4.3605 reviews★ 4.52,651 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.3▲ 0.3$
33Anónimo Ristorante BarMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.8548 reviews---$
34Champion Pizza / ALI BABAMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.8579 reviews---$
35Barilette - Wine Bar & Charcuterie Boards. Breakfast, Lunch & DinnerMiami Beach · Italian★ 5.0324 reviews---$
36Casa Tulia - 🇮🇹 Italian Restaurant in Miami Beach 🍝Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.7714 reviews★ 3.67 reviews--$
37Dolce VitaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.9363 reviews---$
38Collins Pizza - Artisanal NY Style PizzaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.61,050 reviews★ 4.0159 reviews★ 4.41,209 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.0▲ 0.6$
39IT Italian Trattoria LINCOLN RDMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.61,185 reviews---$
40La LocandaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.61,097 reviews★ 4.3481 reviews★ 4.51,578 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.3▲ 0.3$$
41FORNO N9 PizzaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.6910 reviews---$$
42Fratelli La Bufala - Miami BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.53,640 reviews★ 4.11,146 reviews★ 4.44,786 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 4.1▲ 0.4$
43Blozzom PizzaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.7589 reviews★ 4.7167 reviews★ 4.7756 reviews totalGoogle 4.7 / Yelp 4.7·$
44Pizza Rustica South BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.43,497 reviews★ 3.7499 reviews★ 4.23,996 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 3.7▲ 0.7$
45Pizzette MiamiMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.6753 reviews★ 4.4171 reviews★ 4.5924 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.4▲ 0.2$
46Call Me GabyMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.51,709 reviews★ 4.2475 reviews★ 4.42,184 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 4.2▲ 0.3$$
47Pesto Italian CuisineMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.7328 reviews★ 3.618 reviews--$
48Harry's Pizzeria Miami BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.6534 reviews★ 4.4159 reviews★ 4.5693 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.4▲ 0.2$
49Gino’s Bottega ItalianaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.6481 reviews★ 4.4171 reviews★ 4.5652 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.4▲ 0.2$
50Pizza De MiamiMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5728 reviews---$
51Tre RestaurantMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.6379 reviews---$
52The AlleyMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.6345 reviews★ 4.6241 reviews★ 4.6586 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 4.6·$$
53Pizza Bar Miami BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.33,035 reviews★ 3.6931 reviews★ 4.13,966 reviews totalGoogle 4.3 / Yelp 3.6▲ 0.7$
54Greenhouse Cafe & Pizza Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.9142 reviews---$
55Cafe AvantiMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5475 reviews★ 4.2223 reviews★ 4.4698 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 4.2▲ 0.3$
56Rao's Miami BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5441 reviews---$$
57Giotto Maestro della PizzaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5403 reviews★ 4.1290 reviews★ 4.3693 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 4.1▲ 0.4$
58Ezio's Miami Beach Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.7125 reviews---$$
59Spiga Ristorante ItalianoMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5374 reviews----
60The Smoking Pie Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.6245 reviews★ 3.929 reviews★ 4.4274 reviews totalGoogle 4.6 / Yelp 3.9▲ 0.7-
61Bellagio Terrace Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.950 reviews---$
62Marc's Artisanal PizzeriaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5304 reviews★ 3.768 reviews★ 4.2372 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 3.7▲ 0.8$
63Osteria Morini Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5245 reviews★ 4.5147 reviews★ 4.5392 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 4.5·-
64V E Restaurants Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.845 reviews---$
65San Marco Miami Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.760 reviews---$
66Little Caesars PizzaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.3823 reviews★ 2.423 reviews--$
67a'Riva Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.750 reviews---$$
68Joe’s Pizza NYC Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5208 reviews★ 4.240 reviews★ 4.4248 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 4.2▲ 0.3$
69Leonardo Miami Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.645 reviews---$$
70Fialkoff's Kosher PizzaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.3727 reviews★ 3.464 reviews★ 4.1791 reviews totalGoogle 4.3 / Yelp 3.4▲ 0.9$
71La FocacciaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.812 reviews----
72Vincenzos NY Pizza Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5185 reviews---$
73MacchialinaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.41,713 reviews★ 4.1956 reviews★ 4.32,669 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 4.1▲ 0.3$
74Prince Street Pizza Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5165 reviews★ 3.636 reviews★ 4.2201 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 3.6▲ 0.9$
75Forte dei MarmiMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.41,636 reviews★ 4.0331 reviews★ 4.31,967 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 4.0▲ 0.4$$
76Beatrice Pizza Club Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.5118 reviews---$
77Pelican RestaurantMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.4892 reviews★ 3.1353 reviews★ 3.91,245 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 3.1▲ 1.3$$$
78PizzElla - Food Truck Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.768 reviews----
79Sardinia Enoteca RistoranteMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.4699 reviews★ 3.9419 reviews★ 4.21,118 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 3.9▲ 0.5$$
80Vice Kitchen + BarMiami Beach · Italian★ 5.03 reviews----
81Mega Pizza Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.944 reviews---$
82Prima Classe Miami Beach, Italian Market & CafeMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.4348 reviews★ 4.355 reviews★ 4.4403 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 4.3▲ 0.1$$
83Fisher Island Club La Trattoria Restaurant Hidden gemMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.842 reviews----
84LucaliMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.21,765 reviews★ 3.9939 reviews★ 4.12,704 reviews totalGoogle 4.2 / Yelp 3.9▲ 0.3$$
85Pizza FioreMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.2750 reviews★ 3.2168 reviews★ 3.9918 reviews totalGoogle 4.2 / Yelp 3.2▲ 1.0$
86The Italy Cuisine and SmoothieMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.04 reviews★ 3.9108 reviews--$$
87Primo Pizza South BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.2490 reviews----
88Truffle Italian RestaurantMiami Beach · Italian★ 3.54 reviews---$$
89Mom's New York PizzaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.2468 reviews★ 3.9221 reviews★ 4.1689 reviews totalGoogle 4.2 / Yelp 3.9▲ 0.3$
90Beatrice Pizza ClubMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.350 reviews---$
91Restaurant at Casa CasuarinaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.127 reviews---$
92Pizza by StellaMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.01 reviews---$$
93O4W Pizza South BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.04 reviews---$$
94Pizzas 305Miami Beach · Italian★ 1.01 reviews---$$
95Fi'lia South BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.3331 reviews★ 3.817 reviews---
96Pizza N ShakeMiami Beach · Italian★ 2.02 reviews---$$
97Pizza Bar West AveMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.030 reviews----
98Scarpetta by Scott ConantMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.3553 reviews---$$$$
99Mario the BakerMiami Beach · Italian★ 2.86 reviews---$
100Casa Sorbillo - Miami BeachMiami Beach · Italian★ 4.2325 reviews---$

See all categories in Miami Beach · View Miami Beach on the map

Other cuisines in Miami Beach

American · Asian · French · Japanese · Mediterranean · Mexican · Seafood · Steakhouse · Vegan

This ranking compares businesses across every type (restaurant, cafe, bakery, and more) using the same fused quality score used elsewhere on the site, not the type-specific leaderboards above. Every ranking here uses public Google review data only. See the methodology.