Platerian
ENES

Italian in North Miami Beach

17 businessesRanked by quality scoreRanked on Google reviews · Yelp shown for comparisonUpdated July 19, 2026View on map

Right now, the top-rated Italian in North Miami Beach is 1000 Degrees Pizza - North Miami Beach, FL (4.5 stars).

The biggest Google-vs-Yelp gap among Italian spots in North Miami Beach is at Pizza Hut: Google rates it 3.4 stars, Yelp 1.9.

Tatore has the most Google reviews among Italian spots in North Miami Beach (2,491).

17 Italian food businesses in North Miami Beach, ranked by the same fused quality score (Google rating and review volume) used across the rest of the site, from public Google review data.

Found 16 results

#BusinessGoogle ratingYelp ratingCombined ratingGoogle vs. YelpPrice
11000 Degrees Pizza - North Miami Beach, FLNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.5816 reviews---$
2Sarpino's Pizzeria North Miami Beach Hidden gemNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.7177 reviews---$
3TatoreNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.52,491 reviews★ 3.9412 reviews★ 4.32,903 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 3.9▲ 0.6$
4NATE’S PIZZANorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.4403 reviews★ 4.2105 reviews★ 4.3508 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 4.2▲ 0.2$
5Pomodoro's PizzaNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.4257 reviews★ 3.798 reviews★ 4.1355 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 3.7▲ 0.7-
6Ristorante Portovino Hidden gemNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.5185 reviews★ 3.665 reviews★ 4.2250 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 3.6▲ 0.9$
7Bari PizzaNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.1415 reviews★ 3.391 reviews★ 3.8506 reviews totalGoogle 4.1 / Yelp 3.3▲ 0.8$
8Casa Pizza North Miami Beach Hidden gemNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.625 reviews---$
9Wheely Kosher PizzaNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 5.07 reviews----
10Zaza PizzaNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 3.69 reviews----
11SbarroNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 3.831 reviews---$
12Cacio e Pepe Italian RestaurantNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 4.3473 reviews★ 4.0173 reviews★ 4.2646 reviews totalGoogle 4.3 / Yelp 4.0▲ 0.3$
13Pizza Hut ExpressNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 3.649 reviews---$
14Pizza HutNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 3.4615 reviews★ 1.939 reviews★ 3.1654 reviews totalGoogle 3.4 / Yelp 1.9▲ 1.5$
15Papa Johns PizzaNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 3.1386 reviews★ 1.964 reviews★ 2.8450 reviews totalGoogle 3.1 / Yelp 1.9▲ 1.2$
16Domino's PizzaNorth Miami Beach · Italian★ 2.9876 reviews★ 1.534 reviews★ 2.7910 reviews totalGoogle 2.9 / Yelp 1.5▲ 1.4$

See all categories in North Miami Beach · View North Miami Beach on the map

Other cuisines in North Miami Beach

Chinese · Mexican · Vegan

This ranking compares businesses across every type (restaurant, cafe, bakery, and more) using the same fused quality score used elsewhere on the site, not the type-specific leaderboards above. Every ranking here uses public Google review data only. See the methodology.