19 restaurants and food businesses in Bay Harbor Islands
19 businessesGoogle reviews onlyUpdated July 19, 2026
Right now, the top spot overall in Bay Harbor Islands is Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Bay Harbor (a 4.9 combined rating).
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Bay Harbor has the most Google reviews in Bay Harbor Islands (2,624).
The average Google rating in Bay Harbor Islands is 4.6 stars, based on 18 rated businesses.
View Bay Harbor Islands on the map
Best of Bay Harbor Islands
Map
Rankings by category
Frequently asked
What restaurants are in Aventura Mall?
The census covers every food business in Aventura, including the mall's. See the Aventura page.
What is the most popular restaurant in Bay Harbor Islands?
By review volume, Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Bay Harbor tops Bay Harbor Islands with 2,624 Google reviews.
Every ranking here uses public Google review data only. See the methodology.