Best of Bay Harbor Islands right now: Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Bay Harbor
★4.9 combined2,624 reviews#1 of 10Updated July 19, 2026
First edition. No change history yet.
| # | Business | Combined rating | vs avg |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Bay Harbor | +0.8 vs pizzeria+0.6 vs all | |
| 2 | MORLA Restaurant | +0.3 vs restaurant+0.6 vs all | |
| 3 | Mamale Café & Pizza Bar | +0.3 vs restaurant+0.6 vs all | |
| 4 | BobaBurger | +0.6 vs cafe+0.6 vs all | |
| 5 | Pura Vida Miami | +0.4 vs cafe+0.4 vs all | |
| 6 | Coffee Break Enjoy | +0.4 vs cafe+0.4 vs all | |
| 7 | Bay Harbor Café | +0.4 vs cafe+0.4 vs all | |
| 8 | Meat Bar | +0.1 vs restaurant+0.4 vs all | |
| 9 | Qavah Coffee | +0.2 vs restaurant+0.5 vs all | |
| 10 | Mestizo Gastro Fusion | +0.1 vs restaurant+0.4 vs all |
Frequently asked
What is the best restaurant in Bay Harbor Islands right now?
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Bay Harbor holds the #1 spot in the current edition, with a 4.9 combined rating across 2,624 reviews.
How is this list computed?
Combined rating: pooled evidence across every available platform, weighted by the square root of each platform's review count, then adjusted toward this cohort's typical rating when the evidence is thin.
Edition history
Combined rating: pooled evidence across every available platform, weighted by the square root of each platform's review count, then adjusted toward this cohort's typical rating when the evidence is thin. See the methodology.